Coming in at $11.95, the U-Haul Glass Pack Kit was impressive in more than one area, but its price point sets it apart from all the rest. With space for up to 18 glasses, you’re getting a great amount of space too. Kit assembly was a breeze, and everything fit perfectly without forcing dividers into the box. The kit included a box and foam dividers—the only kit on the list to include both.

The box held up well when I stacked and carried it, but it was noticeably thinner than other boxes. Built-in handles were great to have, but I noticed some tears in the handles with a fully-loaded box of up to 65 lbs.

As the cheapest option of the group, the U-Haul Glass Pack Kit gives you decent durability and everything you need to quickly start packing without purchasing extra materials.

The Duck Brand Glass Kit is our pick for best all-in-one kit because of its good size, average price, and satisfactory protection. There are cheaper kits and kits that offer better protection, but the Duck Brand Glass Kit provides enough in each area to be an excellent fit for scenarios like quick apartment moves and packing small boxes for college. 

The kit includes a small box and dividers, giving you nine cells to pack with glasses. Because of its 12-inch depth, you can fit some fairly large items, but you’ll want to buy extra packing materials to secure smaller mugs and glasses at the bottom of the box.

The Home Depot Glass Packing Kit easily took the spot for the most space. Its two-tiered design allows you to basically double what you could fit in other boxes, giving you 30 cells to work with. The kit sells for $11.98 and comes with cardboard cell dividers and a cardboard base to stack your second tier.

The Home Depot Glass Packing Kit didn’t come with a box or any other protection. You will need purchase that separately. The Home Depot sites says you should use the kit with a heavy-duty box, which I highly recommend using.

The standard medium box sells for $1.81, which works in a pinch, but the heavy-duty box was one of the more durable boxes I used. The heavy-duty box costs $3.20, so it can add up if you buy a few, but its double-corrugated cardboard design held up very well under a stacking and carrying test. I felt confident that the built-in handles wouldn’t tear—even with a fully-loaded 75 lbs box. 

The Lowe’s Project Source Glass Packing Kit is the most expensive kit of the group at $19.48 but for good reason. Even without the heavy-duty box option, this sturdily-constructed kit provided strong protection. The box that matches it is just $1.28, with the heavy-duty option being $2.26, though you need to purchase either separately. 

What set this kit apart from the rest was the 12 reusable foam pouches. They were much thicker than the U-Haul pouches and provided much more protection for glassware.

When I assembled this kit, I found that the divider didn’t fit in the box as easily as the other kits. While this slowed down the process, I actually secured the divider in the box much more snugly than in the other kits. Because of this, my glassware felt much more stable when carrying the box. I searched for customer reviews to see if anyone else experienced this, but didn’t find any reports.